Paper accepted at Information Visualisation 2000, Symposium on Digital Libraries.
Searching for the perfect match: A comparison of free sorting results for images by human subjects and by Latent Semantic Analysis techniques
Katy Börner
Indiana University
School of Library and Information Science
10th Street & Jordan Avenue, Main
Library 019
Bloomington, IN. 47405 USA
E-mail: katy@indiana.edu
Abstract
Information visualization can improve
the access and manipulation of digital data if it conforms to human expectations,
and supports the particular interface, task, data, and user. Detailed usability
studies are required to prove this assumption. This paper reports a usability
study of the data analysis algorithm applied in the LVis - Digital Library
Visualizer that spatially visualizes search results derived from
user queries of digital library collections. In particular, it presents
a comparison of free sorting results for image data done by 20 human subjects
and the data analysis result derived via Latent Semantic Analysis from
the textual image descriptions. The results of the study suggest that people,
if asked to categorize with no constraints, will use features that are
often derivable from textual metadata. Human clustering strategies and
resulting demands for image browsing systems are discussed and future work
is outlined.
This Web page provides access to the color figures. Click here to retrieve the pdf version of this paper.
Figure 1: Sorted "African" Data Set
Figure 3: Sorted and Labeled "Bosch" Data Set
Figure 4: MDS Result for "Bosch"
Figure 5: MDS Result for "African"
Figure 6: LSA Result for "Bosch"
Figure 7: LSA Result for "African"
HomeFacultyKaty
BörnerIV-FS00
Publication
http://ella.slis.indiana.edu/~katy/IV-FS
Last modified: 03/06/2000